Cameras Ranked

20 Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G vs 17–28 Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD

Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G vs Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD: our pick for most people is the Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G. Pick the Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G if you carry it all day or travel light, or you shoot in low light or want a blurrier background (weight: 373 g vs 420 g; widest aperture: f/1.8 vs f/2.8). Pick the Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD if you want more reach at the long end, or you want a wider view at the short end (focal length: 20 mm vs 17-28 mm).

To one scale. Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G: length 84.7 mm, diameter 73.5 mm, filter thread 67 mm; Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD: length 99 mm, diameter 73 mm, filter thread 67 mm.84.7 mmSony 20373 g99 mmTamron 17–28420 g
Both to one scale, from each maker's length and diameter, the filter thread in yellow. The rings are drawn, not measured.
To one scale. Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G: length 84.7 mm, diameter 73.5 mm, filter thread 67 mm; Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD: length 99 mm, diameter 73 mm, filter thread 67 mm.84.7 mmSony 20373 g99 mmTamron 17–28420 g
Both to one scale, from each maker's length and diameter, the filter thread in yellow. The rings are drawn, not measured.

The pick, in points

Lead for a pick: 1

Sony 20

5points

Wins on weight and widest aperture.

Tamron 17–28

4points

Wins on focal length (longest) and focal length (widest).

Each real difference scores its importance for the side that wins it; a lead under 1 is “it depends”. How the weights work

The Sony 20 on its ownThe Tamron 17–28 on its ownAll Sony E-mount lenses

Where they differ

4 of 17 specs

Each bar is the gap as a share of the smaller value, on one scale from 0 to 100%; an arrow end is a gap past 100%. The dashed tick marks where a gap starts to count.

  1. Widest aperture

    Importance 3

    Sony 20f/1.81Tamron 17–28f/2.8

    1 apart (55.6%), to the Sony 20

    3points

  2. Weight

    Importance 2

    Sony 20373 g2Tamron 17–28420 g3

    47 g apart (12.6%), to the Sony 20

    2points

  3. Focal length (longest)

    Importance 2

    Sony 2020 mm1Tamron 17–2828 mm

    8 mm apart (40%), to the Tamron 17–28

    2points

  4. Focal length (widest)

    Importance 2

    Sony 2020 mm1Tamron 17–2817 mm4

    3 mm apart (17.6%), to the Tamron 17–28

    2points

Also different, no weight reads them5
  1. Length

    Sony 2084.7 mm2Tamron 17–2899 mm3

    14.3 mm apart (16.9%)

    Not weighted

  2. Diameter

    Sony 2073.5 mm2Tamron 17–2873 mm3

    0.5 mm apart (0.7%)

    Not weighted

  3. Maximum magnification, wide end

    Sony 200.2x2AF modeTamron 17–280.1923x3

    0.008 apart (4%)

    Not weighted

  4. Elements

    Sony 20142Tamron 17–28133

    1 apart (7.7%)

    Not weighted

  5. Groups

    Sony 20122Tamron 17–28113

    1 apart (9.1%)

    Not weighted

Side by side, to scale

Focal length on one log scale

Focal length on one log scale: Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G: 20 to 20 mm; Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD: 17 to 28 mm.Sony 20Tamron 17–28+8 mm−3 mm162435
The focal lengths each maker states.

Specifications

SpecificationsSony FE 20mm F1.8 GTamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD
Focal length20 mm117-28 mm4
Widest aperturef/1.81f/2.8
Closest focus0.19 m (AF mode)20.19 m at 17 mm, 0.26 m at 28 mm3
Maximum magnification0.2x (AF mode)20.1923x at 17 mm, 0.1667x at 28 mm3
TypePrimeZoom
Weight373 g2420 g3
Length84.7 mm299 mm3
Diameter73.5 mm273 mm3
On sale fromNot statedJul 25, 20193
Elements142133
Groups122113
Aperture blades929 (circular diaphragm)3
HoodALC-SH1622Flower-shaped hood3

Same on both

  • Stabilization No
  • Mount Sony E-mount2
  • Covers Full frame
  • Filter thread 67 mm2

Full specifications, side by side†

Show all 2 rows
Full specifications, side by sideSony 202Tamron 17–283
Lens mountLens mount: Sony E-mountLens mount type: SONY E Mount
WeightWeight: 373 gLens weight: 420g (14.8 oz)
Rows only one maker lists: 36

Also on the Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G spec page2

Product nameFE 20mm F1.8 G
Model numberSEL20F18G
Compatible sensor size35mm full-size
Focal length20 mm
Focal length image30 mm (APS-C size sensor)
Lens construction12-14
Angle of view70 (APS-C)
Angle of view94 (35mm format)
Maximum aperture1.8
Minimum aperture22
Diaphragm blades9
Circular diaphragmyes
Minimum focusing distance0.19 m (AF mode)
Minimum focusing distance0.18 m (MF mode)
Maximum magnification ratio0.20 (AF mode)
Maximum magnification ratio0.22 (MF mode)
Filter size67 mm
1.4x teleconverter compatibilityno (1.4x teleconverter)
2.0x teleconverter compatibilityno (2.0x teleconverter)
Hood typepetal-shaped bayonet type
Dimensions73.5×84.7 mm
Included hood modelALC-SH162
Included front cap modelALC-F67S
Included rear cap modelALC-R1EM
Included case typesoft case

Also on the Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD spec page3

Diagonal angle of view103°41'-75°23' (for full-frame mirrorless format)
Optical element and group count13 elements in 11 groups
Minimum object distance wide0.19m (7.5 in) (WIDE)
Minimum object distance tele0.26m (10.2 in) (TELE)
Maximum magnification wide1:5.2 (WIDE)
Maximum magnification tele1:6 (TELE)
Smallest aperture settingF22
Filter thread diameterΦ67mm
Maximum lens diameterΦ73mm
Lens length99mm (3.9 in)
Number of aperture blades9 (circular diaphragm)

How the pick works

  1. Widest aperture3

    Lower wins once they are 0.3 apart.

  2. Weight2

    Lower wins from a 12% gap.

  3. Focal length (longest)2

    Higher wins from a 15% gap.

  4. Focal length (widest)2

    Lower wins once they are 2 mm apart.

  5. Optical stabilization1

    Having it wins.

  6. Closest focus, wide end1

    Lower wins from a 15% gap. Compared only between lenses of the same focal length (widest).

  7. Filter thread0.5

    Lower wins once they are 5 mm apart.

  8. Lead for a pick1

Our pick or our take adds up the importance of each real difference, with these importances and thresholds: a gap smaller than its row's threshold is too close to call and counts as the same. They are our editorial choice, not a measurement, the same on every page, and they never read prices, sales or who sells it.

Paid placements0

How we rank, in full

Sources

  1. Wikidata: Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G, checked Oct 9, 2026 (CC0 1.0)
  2. Sony Japan lens specifications (sony.jp), checked Nov 16, 2026
  3. Tamron product specifications, checked Nov 16, 2026
  4. Wikidata: Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 Di III RXD, checked Oct 9, 2026 (CC0 1.0)

Worked out by code, not stated by a source

  • Read from the lens name: each maker marks the sensor size a lens covers (Sony FE/E, Canon RF/RF-S, Nikon DX, Tamron Di III/Di III-A, Sigma DG/DC); every Fujifilm X lens is APS-C and every Micro Four Thirds lens is Four Thirds.
  • Read from the lens name: Sony marks optically stabilized lenses OSS, Canon IS, Nikon VR, Fujifilm OIS, Panasonic O.I.S., Tamron VC and Sigma OS; a lens from these makers without the mark has no optical stabilization.
  • Prime or zoom, read from the focal length in the lens name.
  • Focal length and widest aperture as the lens's own name states them.

Each value is checked automatically against the source it links, on the date shown. How we build these pages

† The makers' own tables, row by row, with labels in our plain words (translated where the maker's page isn't in English); each row's numbers are checked against the page it links.

What we don't know yet

  • On sale from for the Sony FE 20mm F1.8 G: our sources don't state it yet.

More comparisons